Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Ada Accommodation Fence topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission approves fence variance for disabled veteran after VA medical letter, imposes recording and expiration conditions
Summary
The Canal Winchester Planning & Zoning Commission approved variance VA26011 allowing a rear-yard fence at 7411 Cali Street as a medical reasonable accommodation tied to VA documentation, with conditions including HOA notice, recording, and an expiration when the applicant no longer resides at the property. The decision followed public opposition from the neighborhood HOA.
The Canal Winchester Planning & Zoning Commission on July 13 approved variance VA26011 to allow a rear-yard fence at 7411 Cali Street in the Canal Cove subdivision after staff said the applicant submitted a VA physician recommendation and federal accommodation obligations apply.
Staff told commissioners the applicant provided a letter from a VA physician describing medical needs linked to PTSD and that the relief would be a narrowly tailored reasonable accommodation. "Special conditions and circumstances in this case result from medical diagnosis and recommendation from a VA physician," staff said while recommending approval with four conditions, including that the permit expire on property transfer and a recorded notice be placed with the county recorder to alert future buyers.
Fatima Sabir, who identified herself as the applicant's spouse and the veteran's VA-authorized caregiver, said the veteran is a more-than-100% disabled retiree and that the home modifications are funded under the VA SHA housing-accommodation program. "We respectfully ask the commission, to honor the medical directive provided by Doctor Muhammad, respect the intent of the VA's SHH program, and just comply with federal reasonable accommodation standards and approve these variants tonight so that my husband can, enjoy his home and I can safely care for him," Sabir told the commission.
Neighbors spoke in opposition at the public hearing, arguing the subdivision's deed restrictions and HOA rules prohibit fences and that approving the variance could set a precedent. Tim Bruni, identifying himself as the homeowners association president, said the HOA had never approved fencing in Canal Cove and urged alternatives such as plantings and pergolas. Neighbor Chris Paul Putnis said allowing the fence could open a "Pandora's box" of future requests.
Commissioners discussed enforcement and monitoring; staff and legal counsel said a recorded notice and a condition that the approval expire when the resident no longer lives at the property would help limit the relief to the individual applicant and preserve HOA rights. The commission adopted the staff conditions with amended language for condition 1 to specify that the permit expires when the applicant no longer resides at the property.
Motion and outcome: Commissioner Gooden moved to approve VA26011 with staff conditions as amended; the motion was seconded and passed by roll call of the members present (all voting yes). The approval included the four staff-recommended conditions plus the amended expiration language and a requirement that the homeowner pursue any HOA approvals separately.
What happens next: The permit will be recorded per the condition so future buyers will be notified, and the fence approval will be tied to the applicant's residency; if the property changes hands or the applicant no longer resides there, the permit must be removed per the adopted condition.
