Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Sidewalks topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Greenburgh board debates creating sidewalk district amid safety and cost concerns
Summary
Town board members debated whether to form a sidewalk district to shift repair and snow-removal responsibilities from homeowners to the town, with proponents citing safety near train stations and opponents citing cost and liability concerns.
Chair opened discussion of a proposed sidewalk district, noting decades of town sidewalk maintenance in neighborhoods such as Edgemont and saying safety concerns—particularly near steep approaches to the Scarsdale train station—have made the issue urgent. “I sort of feel that the town should either continue doing what we’ve done, which is maintaining the sidewalks,” the Chair said, arguing that unsafe sidewalks push pedestrians into roadways.
A council member cautioned that asking the town to assume maintenance could create significant cost and liability. That member said the town risks assuming responsibility for hazards and should consider a formal assessment study before acting. “We are otherwise assuming a huge cost, and we’re assuming liability,” the council member said.
Staff told the board that no DPW work on a sidewalk district has begun and that staff will not proceed without explicit board direction; the town’s creation of any sidewalk district would follow town-law protocol and require public hearings for each district. Staff recommended asking Commissioner Fawn (DPW) to detail operational impacts and Assessor McCarthy to model per-household assessment costs.
Council members offered alternatives: creating neighborhood-level districts, a single townwide district, or limiting town responsibility to code-defined, heavily used roads where sidewalk maintenance is most critical. One council member said town plows currently serve some sidewalks but not others, calling that inequitable and urging the board to use roads already identified in the town code to guide decisions. “We actually have town personnel plowing some sidewalks in front of homes and not others,” the council member said.
Board members discussed contracting with private vendors for snow removal, additional insurance costs, and the effect of assigning maintenance responsibility on residents’ willingness to accept new sidewalks near their homes. The board agreed to request cost and assessment analyses from DPW and the assessor and to return to the item after those figures are available.
The board did not adopt any ordinance or formal motion on the sidewalk district during the work session; members directed staff to prepare studies and cost estimates as the next step.
