Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Sports Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Belgrade board approves limited 8th-grade participation in high-school sports, 6-1
Summary
After public testimony and months of discussion, the Belgrade School Board voted 6-1 to approve revisions to policy 3510 allowing 8th graders to participate in high-school athletics under a procedure the district will finalize; the board approved Option 2, permitting soccer and wrestling to include 8th graders.
The Belgrade School Board on an evening meeting approved revisions to board policy 3510 that let eighth-grade students be considered for participation on high-school athletic teams, adopting Option 2 to allow the practice for soccer and wrestling and directing district administrators to finalize implementation procedures.
The board’s action followed more than two hours of public comment and a lengthy staff presentation distinguishing policy from procedure. Stevens (a board member who moved the final motion) said the board would approve the policy while the superintendent and athletic staff would write and apply a procedure specifying how and when 8th graders may join varsity or junior-varsity rosters.
Supporters — parents, students and coaches — told the board the policy was needed to shore up shrinking rosters and rebuild programs. Liberty Brown, a local parent, said her research on Title IX underscored the stakes: “I feel like over the last 48 hours, I’ve become an expert in Title IX,” she told the board, urging them to adopt a policy that would preserve opportunities for girls’ teams. Dr. Robert Lemley, head boys’ soccer coach, asked the board, “What harm could come from this?” and called the change a ‘‘win-win’’ for participation and competitiveness. Bryce Weatherston, the head wrestling coach, said the chance would create more opportunities to develop athletes and build successful programs.
District officials and board members pressed for guardrails. Presenters explained the draft divides sports into team sports and individual varsity sports, applies a team-by-team participation threshold (a 175% target roster number was cited in the discussion), and requires a multi-step approval process: a coach’s recommendation would go to the athletic director and principal and could be elevated to the superintendent for final approval. Julie, a middle-school educator who spoke during the meeting, explained how standards-based grades would be converted to percentage grades and emphasized that eligibility would remain dependent on academic standing and behavior.
Some board members and commenters urged caution. One board member said limiting the policy to only a few sports risked Title IX challenges and suggested a narrow trial (two sports) with review; another expressed concerns about developmentally younger students riding high-school buses and the emotional impact on older players who might see playing time reduced.
After debate the board amended the motion to approve the policy with procedures attached and voted 6-1 in favor of Option 2 (allowing 8th graders to be considered for soccer and wrestling). The board directed staff to work with the Montana School Boards Association (MTSBA) and legal counsel as needed to finalize the procedural language and to bring any required follow-up back to the board. The motion passed on roll call, six yes and one no.
What happens next: administrators will finalize the procedure that implements the policy, following the approval chain discussed at the meeting; the board said it will revisit the policy or procedure if problems arise.
