Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Health Insurance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Outside consultant offers review as county faces a 43% health-insurance renewal
Summary
An independent benefits consultant asked Washington County commissioners to allow a review of claims data after the county received a proposed ~43% insurance renewal; staff outlined options including a single HSA-qualified plan with a $1,000-per-employee seed that could cut the renewal's impact.
An outside consultant told Washington County commissioners he could review the county's health-plan claims and seek savings after the county received a proposed 43% renewal.
"I'm Tyler Neal with JA Benefits," the consultant said, describing a recent audit for another county that reduced a proposed 92% increase and urging the commissioners to let his firm compete when procurement allows. Commissioners said the county must follow a formal bid process that requires advertising and a minimum timeline and that the renewal's Sept. 1 effective date limits solicitation this year.
County staff reported they received proposals from UnitedHealthcare and SCIO and that Angle Health (using the Cigna network) said the county's group was not competitive. Staff said the county's current expiring premium is about $1.4 million and the renewal would exceed $2.1 million. One staff-presented option was moving to a single HSA-qualified high-deductible plan (with a $4,000 tier for in-network providers and a $5,000 tier for some out-of-network providers) and seeding employees' HSAs to blunt the impact.
Staff gave a numeric scenario: a single-plan annual base cost of about $1,457,001.68; seeding $1,000 per enrolled employee (census roughly 140) would raise the total to about $1,597,001.68 — an additional roughly $170,002.47 over expiring rates — which staff said would reduce the renewal impact to nearly a flat or low-double-digit increase instead of 43%.
Commissioners and staff discussed trade-offs: limiting employee choice versus keeping premiums manageable, provider network tiers and the effect on deductibles for users of certain hospitals, and how seeding and participation in the county clinic could affect overall costs. Staff said clinic participation was roughly half of enrolled employees and encouraged higher utilization to capture savings.
The consultant said his firm would like to be allowed to bid when the county's procurement window opens and reiterated he was not asking the board to circumvent the required bid process.
Next steps: staff will continue negotiations with Anthem and follow up with additional carrier responses; the county indicated it will consider options at an upcoming public meeting and return with final numbers for any change in plan design or provider.
