Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Design Review Standards topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Topia seeks synthetic signboard; HLC asks staff to confirm design-review compatibility
Summary
An applicant for a Topia façade grant asked whether a flush black signboard of PVC/vinyl or composite material would be acceptable. Commissioners noted the design-review standards generally favor historically-appropriate materials; staff (James) said he would check whether engineered cement board or composite profiles would meet the standards or whether a new COA is required.
A Topia representative and contractor discussed replacing an awning with a flush black signboard and proposed using a PVC or composite backboard rather than traditional wood. Commissioners reviewed the commission’s design-review guidance and recalled previous approvals of cementitious boards (Hardie) and composite products when they closely replicate historic wood texture and profile.
The applicant’s contractor argued that plywood or painted exterior plywood would quickly rot and suggested PVC or PVC-board or engineered cement board as longer-lasting alternatives. Commissioners said materials that visibly mimic historic wood profiles and do not read as modern vinyl are more likely to be acceptable; James, the city staff member, said the HLC’s standards "are unlikely to approve installation of any simulated materials, including vinyl, that is unavailable or unlikely to be used at the time of construction," but that engineered cement board or appropriately profiled composite has been accepted in prior cases. James said he would double-check whether the proposed material requires a new COA or could be approved administratively within the current façade grant scope.
Why this matters: Sign materials and finish affect the visual character of historic commercial streetscapes. The commission’s guidance will influence applicant decisions about material selection and potentially the cost of the sign program.
What’s next: James will follow up with the applicant and advise whether a revised COA is needed and which materials would satisfy design-review standards.
