Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the HCR5 topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee endorses resolution affirming Idaho's right to prosecute state crimes despite federal pardons; debate centers on Dr. Fauci reference
Summary
The committee voted to send HCR 5 to the floor with a do-pass recommendation; the resolution states that a presidential pardon does not negate state prosecution and explicitly references Dr. Anthony Fauci, prompting both support and objections.
The Senate State Affairs Committee voted to send HCR 5 — a resolution stating the Legislature's findings that a federal pardon does not confer immunity from state prosecution — to the floor with a do-pass recommendation.
Senator Toews said the resolution affirms Idaho's intent to uphold the rule of law and to allow state prosecution of state crimes regardless of federal pardons; he cited public concern about pandemic-era policies and specifically referenced Dr. Anthony Fauci. Senator Anthon supported the resolution, describing it as an expression of opinion and recounting personal grievances about pandemic policies. Senator Ruchti opposed the measure, saying it inflamed tensions and that singling out Dr. Fauci implied criminality he did not accept.
Senator Shippy noted public perception about a presidential pardon of Dr. Fauci and its timing. The committee adopted the motion to send HCR 5 to the floor by voice vote; the minutes record that Senator Ruchti asked to be recorded as voting nay.
The resolution, as described in committee discussion, is an opinion statement of the Legislature clarified to apply to any federal pardon; the committee did not enact any statute in these segments but advanced the resolution for further consideration on the Senate floor.
