Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Designation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission declines to recommend local support for Erie Municipal Building historic nomination
Summary
The Planning Commission failed to recommend the Erie Municipal Building’s local historic designation after contentious debate about process, preservation goals and the effect of national-listing on future city use; commissioners discussed sending council a summary letter of concerns.
The City of Erie Planning Commission voted against recommending local support for the Erie Municipal Building’s historic nomination after a heated discussion about process, preservation and the building’s future use.
Staff told the commission the Municipal Building at 626 State Street was recently listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which makes the property eligible for certain grant programs and historic tax credits. Planning staff and the Historic Review Commission recommended designation based on the building’s history as the seat of municipal government and its architectural significance.
Several commissioners objected. One described the building as “one of the ugliest buildings I think I’ve ever seen” and said local designation would hamstring future options for that downtown site. Another commissioner raised procedural concerns about the national listing preceding a full local discussion and argued local designation carries regulatory weight that could limit future redevelopment options. “Getting national designation before we even have the discussion at the local level is putting the cart before the horse,” a commissioner said.
Supporters of the nomination pointed out that national listing is largely honorary but opens funding opportunities that could allow the city to repair mechanical systems and restore the lobby. Staff said the listing enables applications for construction funding and historic tax credits that otherwise would be unavailable. One staff member noted prior efforts to seek grants to fix steam vents and other building systems.
When the commission voted on a motion to recommend the nomination to city council, the motion failed. Commissioners then discussed preparing a letter and report to transmit to council summarizing the commission’s concerns and the arguments made during the meeting.
The commission’s non‑recommendation does not block the matter; the nomination will proceed to city council, which will hold a public hearing and make the final determination. Staff said the planning commission’s report will be transmitted to council for consideration.
