Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Procurement Special Magistrate topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves single‑bid special magistrate contract after debate over conflicts and bidder pool
Summary
After debate about a single response to the RFP and perceived conflicts of interest, the commission approved hiring the lone bidder for special magistrate services by roll call (3–1).
The New Smyrna Beach City Commission approved a contract for special magistrate services after a contested discussion about the RFP process and a single bidder.
Commissioners debated whether to reject the lone response and rebid after public comment and concerns from Commissioner Martin and Cindy Snusak about judicial experience and the appearance of conflicts. Snusak urged the commission to reject the response because only one firm applied and that submission appeared to miss qualification bullets in the RFP.
City attorney advised the commission that the issues cited represented a perceived conflict, not a legal disqualification, and noted the bidder had voluntarily agreed to recuse itself from matters in which it had prior involvement. Commissioners expressed concern about the limited responses but said there had been extensive outreach to potential firms. The city attorney said the RFP reached more than 2,175 firms/individuals and was extended due to lack of responses.
Commissioner McGurk said he preferred not to leave the magistrate position vacant and was comfortable proceeding under the circumstances; Commissioner Martin and others voiced concern but ultimately the commission voted in favor.
The motion to approve the contract passed on a roll call: Commissioner McGurk and Commissioner Ashley and the mayor voted yes; Vice Mayor Martin voted no.
The commission instructed staff that if concerns arise later they can reissue an RFP; the contract term described by staff runs three years with two optional one‑year renewals (total of up to five years).
