Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves Hops & Barley patio with conditions on design, noise mitigation and security
Summary
The Planning Commission approved a conditional use permit for a permanent 1,988‑sq‑ft outdoor covered seating area at Hops & Barley Ale House (3905 Tweedy Boulevard) with conditions including acoustic mitigation, 24‑hour surveillance, and on‑site security tied to permitted live‑music events.
The South Gate Planning Commission on July 21 approved Conditional Use Permit 26‑06 and PL 25‑0053 for a permanent outdoor covered seating area at Hops & Barley Ale House, 3905 Tweedy Boulevard, adopting a CEQA Class 3 exemption and directing staff to finalize resolution language with the commission’s amendments.
Planning Manager John Signall told the commission the proposed permanent canopy is approximately 1,988 square feet and would increase the restaurant’s licensed service area for alcohol. The patio design proposed by the applicants includes a covered enclosure with seating and televisions; staff noted the applicant intends no live entertainment outdoors and that live entertainment would be considered separately by the City Council. Staff recommended approval with conditions to ensure noise attenuation, higher‑quality architectural materials and public‑safety measures.
The staff report described several constraints and controls: the temporary pandemic‑era patio remains unpermitted and has been the subject of multiple code‑enforcement citations since 2023; a two‑day ambient baseline noise study predicted patio noise at the nearest residences to be 20–31 decibels (below the city’s standard of 50 dB daytime / 40 dB nighttime). The noise study recommended mitigation (acoustic blankets/curtains and other measures) and staff included related conditions. Staff also recommended a condition requiring a 24‑hour video surveillance system covering the outdoor service area and training for management on footage access for police investigations.
Applicants Sergio and Catherine Vasquez said they purchased the property recently and scaled the design back for cost reasons; they said the patio improves customer comfort and planned to roll down vinyl acoustic curtains at night or during events. Residents near the site objected strongly during public comment, citing repeated late‑night noise, fights, public urination, trash and a perceived lack of enforcement. Supporters including local teachers and regular patrons said the patio supports community gatherings and economic activity on the Tweedy Boulevard corridor.
After extended deliberation about the corridor’s design standards, enforcement history and neighborhood impacts, a commissioner moved to approve the conditional use permit but to strike condition 16 (which would have required returning to an earlier higher‑quality design) and to add language requiring on‑site security for permitted live‑music events. The motion was seconded and passed on roll call. Staff said it will draft revised resolution language reflecting the amended motion and return it for finalization at a subsequent meeting.
Conditions included (but are not limited to) acoustic mitigation measures from the noise study, a requirement that alcohol sales cease one hour before closing, a 24‑hour video surveillance system with 72‑hour minimum retention, and management training and coordination with police for access to footage. The approval also added an expectation that when the City Council later approves any live entertainment permit for indoor live music, on‑site security will be required for live‑music performances as part of the CUP compliance.
The commission directed staff to refine the resolution to reflect the change in conditions and to return the document at a future meeting for formal adoption.
