Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Insurance consultant flags double-digit renewal; commission asks for options to limit impact
Summary
City commissioners heard that health-insurance claims rose sharply this year and that the current Blue Cross renewal would raise premiums well into double digits. The presenter identified options — raise the carrier deductible from $5,000 to $6,000, adjust member out-of-pocket design, or use reserves — and commissioners asked staff for detailed side-by-side scenarios.
Mike Minton, who presented the city’s renewal packet, told commissioners the city is facing an unusually large renewal cycle. “This year is probably in my 25 years of doing this one of the worst years when it comes to renewals,” he said, citing a jump in plan-paid claims from about $596,000 in the prior reporting year to roughly $800,000 in the current 12-month period.
Minton said pharmacy spending for the city actually declined in the most recent reporting period but that a small number of high-cost claimants and other trends pushed the overall claims total upward. He told commissioners Blue Cross’s initial renewal reflected about a 22% increase on the existing fully insured umbrella (an approximately $195,000 increase on an $887,000 premium), and then walked them through plan-design options to reduce that impact.
Among choices presented: shift the Blue Cross umbrella deductible from $5,000 to $6,000 (estimated to save about $47,000), adjust the employee out-of-pocket design under the city’s “freedom” secondary plan, or temporarily use reserve funding to smooth the increase. “If you move that one step to $6,000, you can save $47,000,” Minton said. He also described a higher-deductible option with larger premium savings but cautioned it may reduce member value.
Commissioners asked staff to return with concrete spreadsheets modeling several scenarios, including a $6,000 umbrella deductible, modest changes to employee coinsurance levels, and a range of targeted premium-increase targets (they discussed 10%–15% as planning reference points). The presenter said staff could provide those options at the next meeting so commissioners and employees could review trade-offs before a final decision.
What happens next: staff will prepare written comparisons of the proposed renewal options (including impacts on city costs, employee out-of-pocket exposure, and reserve usage) for a follow-up meeting.
