Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Staff Recommendation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning staff recommends denying demolition at 625 Minnesota, cites limits of demolition exemptions in historic districts
Summary
Planning Department staff told the Landmarks Commission the library site lies within local environs and a state-listed downtown historic district and that the code allows demolition only in narrow circumstances; staff therefore recommended denial of the certificate of appropriateness.
Alyssa Marcy of the Planning Department told the commission that the downtown library at 625 Minnesota Avenue falls within the environs of local historic districts and is part of the downtown commercial historic district that was listed by the State Historic Preservation Office in 2024. Under current code and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation, Marcy said, there are only two narrow exemptions that would allow demolition: if a structure is not visible from the street or if the demolition is paired with rehabilitation that follows the Secretary of the Interior's guidelines. Marcy told commissioners staff had recommended denial on that basis.
Marcy also noted that because the City is a Certified Local Government (CLG), the Planning Department can perform the state-law review on the city's behalf but the SHPO still retains the ability to perform its own review within a 30-day window. "For a state law review, we're following the state law at this point, and the state law also does not allow for demolition of historic sites. So that is why staff has recommended this for denial," she said.
Staff answered commissioners' technical questions about when a future design for a new building would return to the commission for review and explained that approval of demolition would not bypass the certificate-of-appropriateness process for a subsequent proposed design.
