Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Procurement Ethics topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission debate rekindles over —cone of silence— procurement rule
Summary
Commissioner Joseph asked the City Commission to relax the city—s cone-of-silence rules so elected officials and knowledgeable staff could advise procurement before bids are released; city attorneys and managers cautioned the restriction prevents undue vendor influence and preserves fairness.
Commissioner Joseph urged the City Commission to reconsider the city's cone-of-silence rules during a workshop discussion, saying the policy now prevents commissioners and knowledgeable staff from providing input to procurement and contributes to higher costs. "We're just losing hundreds of thousands of dollars, according to that process," Joseph said, calling for more open exchanges with procurement staff.
The city attorney responded that the cone of silence was adopted to prevent entanglements, interference and vendor courting and that Sunny Isles Beach rejoined countywide procedures in 2022. "Cones of silence have been sort of born of necessity because of entanglements, interference, influence, and things of that sort," the city attorney told the commission, urging caution about commissioners communicating with vendors. The attorney cited the ethics code (code 2-11.1) and noted exceptions exist for communications routed through the city manager or procurement staff.
City management said elected officials may request information through the city manager or procurement, but they should not negotiate or direct procurement staff. The city manager said budget lines and procurement processes are public and that procurement uses subject-matter experts to draft scopes of work. "If you allow your influence, then we would be choosing vendors that you like," the city manager said, arguing that the rule helps preserve competitive fairness.
Commissioners were divided: Vice Mayor Viscara said she was "not interested in changing anything" and favored retaining the rule to keep vendors on equal footing; another commissioner said the cone of silence makes vendor calls uncomfortable and that staff can be asked to provide relevant information. The attorney and staff outlined that some communications to procurement are permitted but noted selection-committee members and designated evaluators may not be contacted.
The commission did not vote to repeal the rule but requested clearer definitions and a review of the ordinance language so members are discussing the same scope of restrictions. The discussion concluded with multiple commissioners saying they would refer specific procurement questions to the city manager and procurement director rather than engage directly with vendors.
What happens next: the city attorney offered to forward the cone-of-silence text to the commission for clarification; no repeal or formal amendment was approved during the workshop.
