Residents split on selling Monmouth’s 1856 Academy or forming nonprofit to preserve it

Monmouth residents and members of the town’s 18 56 committee gave sharply contrasting views on whether the town should sell the 1856 Academy or pursue nonprofit stewardship and long-term leasing.

Supporters framed the building as a cultural anchor. Rue Johnson (speaker 12), who said she was a supporter, said the academy ‘‘is an institution’’ and asked town leaders to consider ‘‘what quality of life do you want for your kids growing up in this community?’’ Committee member Larry Gucci (speaker 11) described a model where the town retains ownership of the land and leases a nonprofit the building for a long-term, low-cost lease so the nonprofit would pay utilities and maintenance.

Opponents argued the project has repeatedly failed to win broad voter backing and that continuing to subsidize it would burden taxpayers. Joe Saunders (speaker 3) said he is on Social Security and cannot afford continuing tax increases; several speakers cited previous votes and said roughly 450 voted in favor while about 780 opposed a $187,000 bond vote. David Galanda (speaker 14) urged the select board to put a clear yes/no warrant article on the November ballot asking whether the town should sell the building, and suggested deed restrictions to protect historic exteriors if sold.

Discussion also included practical reuse ideas — farmer’s markets, artist shows, music lessons and rentals — that residents said could generate modest revenue while the town decides a long-term path. The forum closed without a decision to sell; instead the select board later voted to pause new fundraising while the town explores nonprofit formation and ballot options.