Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Abatement Litigation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board discusses denied commercial abatements including 15 Leonard Street and moves to executive session on litigation strategy
Summary
The assessors reviewed denied commercial abatements (notably 15 Leonard Street), discussed the cost of appraisals and potential Appellate Tax Board proceedings, and voted to enter executive session to discuss litigation strategy without returning to open session.
The Norton Board of Assessors reviewed commercial abatement cases at the July 21 meeting, including a contested property at 15 Leonard Street where staff said the building is largely vacant and the town has denied the abatement application.
Staff explained settlement negotiations: a full Appellate Tax Board (ATB) appeal would require an appraisal (estimated in discussion at $10,000–$15,000 for commercial matters) and legal representation, which could make litigation costlier than a negotiated tax-dollar settlement. As an example, staff said a potential town settlement figure for one case would translate to roughly $40,000 in foregone tax revenue—an amount still below the combined appraisal and legal costs that a contested ATB hearing could incur.
One member argued the town should not routinely grant large abatements to commercial property owners to avoid setting precedent, while others cautioned that litigation strategy and settlement posture are sensitive and should be handled in executive session. A motion to enter executive session to discuss litigation strategy was moved, seconded, and approved by voice vote; the chair declared the board would not return to open session.
No public vote overturning prior abatement denials occurred; the board directed staff to follow the previously recorded denials and to proceed with legal or settlement steps as appropriate during the executive-session discussion.
