Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Administration topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Votes at a glance: April 25 Board of Assessment Appeals (Middlebury)
Summary
Summary list of motions and recorded outcomes from the April 25, 2026 meeting: multiple assessment reductions approved, several appeals denied for insufficient evidence, one construction-grade change, and administrative approvals; all recorded votes were unanimous.
The board recorded the following actions at the April 25 meeting (motions carried unanimously unless noted):
• Reduce Market Value to $670,000 and Assessed Value to $469,000 for 139 Burr Hall Rd (Gugliotti). • Deny appeals for Olymbec Preston Park LP parcels near Benson Rd for insufficient evidence (Robin Stern). • Accept appraisal-based values for multiple residential properties, including Buy or Sell Realty LLC (372 Tucker Hill Rd) Market Value $1,375,000/Assessed $962,500; David & Heather Messina (6 West Lake Rd) Market Value $1,150,000/Assessed $805,000; Paul J. Fabian (404 Tucker Hill Rd) Market Value $1,035,000/Assessed $724,500; Paul & Silvana Masucci (194 Artillery Rd) Market Value $1,066,000/Assessed $746,725. • Lindsey Rizzo (95 Porter Ave) Market Value $546,000/Assessed $382,200; John Kuhner & Celenne Mendoza Rosario (760 Watertown Rd) Market Value $640,000/Assessed $448,000; Robert Jenkins (121 Tyler Crossing) Market Value $560,000/Assessed $392,000; Gradia McKinney (2 Chatham Ct) Market Value $635,000/Assessed $444,500; Michael & Janis Carnaroli (7 West Lake Rd) Market Value $1,200,000/Assessed $840,000 (reduced despite appraisal deficiencies). • 417 Highland LLC (137 Falcon Crest Rd — Marcos de Escobar): construction grade changed from B+ to C; Market Value set to $866,700/Assessed $606,690. • Additional topographical and obsolescence adjustments: J & L Properties LLC (41 Glenwood Rd) Market Value $312,100/Assessed $218,960; Old Store LLC (564 Middlebury Rd) Market Value $454,100/Assessed $317,870; DM Interests (Three Mile Hill Rd) Market Value $107,900/Assessed $75,530. • Board approved administrative changes and authorized usual and customary payments. The meeting adjourned at 12:16 p.m.
