Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the RS32880C1 topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee advances RS 32880C1, clarifying courts must apply U.S. and Idaho law
Summary
Senate Judiciary & Rules members voted to send RS 32880C1 to print; the draft would bar use in state courts of religious or cultural law that does not conform with U.S. and Idaho constitutional rights, and committee members debated scope and religious-freedom concerns.
Senator Dan Foreman introduced RS 32880C1, explaining the draft statute would prevent any body of religious or cultural law that does not fully support the rights guaranteed in the U.S. and Idaho Constitutions from being used in state courts. Foreman emphasized the bill does not ban private religious practice and said the measure was coordinated with the Idaho Supreme Court and the state Attorney General, who raised no concerns during the bill’s drafting.
Committee members asked for clarification about the bill’s purpose and potential constitutional conflicts. Senator Wintrow asked what the legislation would accomplish; Foreman said it affirms that state courts should rely on established U.S. and Idaho law and that the bill is preemptive in preventing another body of law from supplanting existing legal systems. Senator Ruchti raised concerns about possible conflicts with religious-freedom protections; Foreman responded that the bill is intended to support, not override, constitutional protections.
Senator Lenney moved and Senator Keyser seconded to send the draft statute to print. The motion carried by voice vote; the minutes do not include a roll-call tally. The committee record reflects that this item was advanced to print for further drafting and consideration.
