Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Budget And Finance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
County commissioners question $40M transit plan’s cost per rider and alternatives
Summary
Several commissioners and a mayor challenged the 10-year TDP’s cost-effectiveness at the Hernando Citrus MPO meeting, citing low farebox recovery and suggesting voucher or on-demand alternatives. Benesch said the TDP is a vision plan and not an economic impact analysis.
Board members pressed the consultant on whether the proposed service expansions represent a fiscally responsible use of taxpayer funds in a largely non-urban county. Commissioner Steve Champion said he calculated a per‑rider cost of about $208 and called that "craziness," while another board member suggested a back-of-the-envelope $133 per rider figure.
"That's the math. It's $133 per rider," said a board member during the discussion, arguing the plan’s per-rider cost merits scrutiny. Mayor Joe May and other commissioners proposed that localities consider travel vouchers, public-private partnerships or on-demand services as potentially lower-cost alternatives. Mayor Meek said, "it would be cheaper to just to pace an Uber to get folks to wherever they need to go than all of pay for all of this and the and the vans and the buses."
Kayla Hutton, the Benesch presenter, answered that the TDP is a strategic vision and not an economic impact analysis: "No, the TDP is more of a vision plan, but there is no economic impact analysis for this." She also noted that projected revenues anticipated for the plan are a mix of federal, state and local funds and that some elements depend on discretionary grants.
The exchange left the board with a choice between advancing a vision to inform grant applications and pursuing more targeted operational analyses (such as a Comprehensive Operations Analysis) to assess alternatives and fiscal trade-offs.
