Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Rezoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council blocks rezoning of 1114 Jeffrey Drive amid neighborhood objections
Summary
Councilors voted down first reading of an ordinance to rezone 1114 Jeffrey Drive from RSL to RSM after extensive public comment raising density, duplexes, tax and equity concerns; the motion failed 5–2, and the applicant must wait a year to reapply.
The Town of James Island council rejected a first‑reading motion to rezone 1114 Jeffrey Drive from low‑density single‑family (RSL) to moderate‑density suburban residential (RSM), after residents and several councilors raised questions about density, potential duplexes and community impact.
Applicant John Schumacher told the council he intended to build a home for his family and that the property (0.93 acres) would allow up to three dwelling units under RSM; he emphasized his present plan is a single family home. "My only intentions and plans I have right now is to build a house for my family," Schumacher said. Residents countered that neighbors lacked clear information about potential short‑term rentals, tax effects and whether the property would be subdivided or sold later.
Planning director Kristen Crane told council that the planning commission had unanimously recommended rezoning, noting the lot is about 0.93 acres and that RSM allows up to four units per acre (so the parcel could legally accommodate three units). Council debate focused on neighborhood character, historic parcel sizing and whether the applicant bears the burden to demonstrate future plans. Several council members said they were sympathetic to the applicant but concerned about placing the onus on an underserved neighborhood to oppose rezoning.
On the vote for first reading, the motion to approve failed 5–2. Mayor Brooke Lyon noted that if the council had not approved first reading, the applicant cannot reapply for a year. Councilors suggested the applicant could return with clearer plans if he wishes to pursue a change later.
