Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Truck Route topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission recommends extending high-frequency truck routes on West Main, West A and West M streets after heated public comment
Summary
After extensive public comment and discussion about drainage, safety and grandfathered uses, the commission recommended that City Council add sections of West Main (Spencer Hwy), West A Street and West M Street to the city’s high-frequency truck-route list, a zoning designation that allows certain heavy-truck generating uses to locate adjacent to those streets.
The Planning & Zoning Commission voted to recommend three separate text amendments to section 106.7.46 of the La Porte code to designate additional high-frequency truck-route segments: West Main/Spencer Highway (from South 16th Street approximately 1,000 feet west to the rail corridor), West A Street (from South 16th approximately 630 feet to its terminus) and West M Street (South 16th west to the railroad right-of-way).
City staff described the legal difference between truck-route prohibitions enforced by police and the zoning-based concept of a high-frequency truck route (a zoning designation tied to certain NAICS codes that require adjacency to the route). "Section 106.7.46 of the La Porte code has a designated list of routes which are designated as high frequency truck routes," Ryan Beatluk said, explaining the NAICS codes (freight trucking, specialized trucking, warehousing/storage) that require adjacency.
Public speakers were sharply split. Residents including Larry Haller and Stephanie Cardenas opposed adding truck-route designations along small streets, citing chronic drainage problems, safety concerns and frequent 18-wheeler intrusions. "Our parking lot today looks like a puddle, a gigantic puddle," Cardenas said, and called the feeder roads and overpass area unsafe given existing truck behavior. Business owners and long-standing property owners including Gus Bridal and Alton Ogden argued that some properties had been used by trucks for decades and that removing truck-route status earlier harmed livelihoods; Bridal noted his operation was grandfathered and said the property recently listed could fetch $6,000,000.
Commissioners weighed infrastructure limits, grandfathering/continuous-use rules and the possibility that denying a route could push the market to accept even more intense uses. They approved West Main first, then West A, and later West M (Port Crossing area) by separate motions. Commissioners asked staff to include clarifying language on continuous-use/grandfathering and to forward the recommendations to City Council.
