Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Surveillance And Privacy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Shaker Heights backs new contract limits and audits for Flock license-plate camera data
Summary
The law director said Flock agreed to contract changes that bar voluntary disclosure of city footage except under a valid court-issued warrant and add material-breach and audit-log protections; police presented case examples and usage data but council members pressed for more outcome information on immigration-related searches.
The council spent an extended portion of the work session reviewing the city's contract and operational practices for the Flock license-plate camera system.
The city's law director said recent negotiations removed contract language that might have permitted third-party hosting or broad disclosure of city footage, added a material-breach clause allowing termination and recovery of fees, and required Flock to resist non-judicial requests when possible. "Flock is specifically not allowed to access, use, preserve, or disclose any of the city's footage or data to any governmental authority or third parties except pursuant to a valid search warrant issued by a court," the law director said.
Police leadership presented detailed examples of investigative uses: locating stolen vehicles, supporting aggravated-robbery or violent-crime investigations, finding missing or endangered persons, and helping reduce dangerous vehicle pursuits by enabling follow-up investigations rather than immediate high-speed chases. Lieutenant Troy Allison presented a one-week snapshot of hot-list hits that included hundreds of regional alerts; in the sample week staff recorded 419 hot-list hits in the system (tracked regionally) with manual non-owned hot-list entries that included sample counts such as 59 offender hits, 11 warrants and 8 stolen-plate alerts in that snapshot. Staff emphasized that hot-list alerts are notifications and do not by themselves authorize a traffic stop; officers still need reasonable suspicion or other lawful grounds.
Council members repeatedly raised privacy and immigration concerns. The vice mayor noted that compiled regional logs showed 273 instances in recent months where search terms related to immigration appeared in searches that included Shaker Heights cameras; staff said they could not always trace outcomes (for example, whether searches led to detentions or deportations) because many searches originate outside the city and Flock does not provide downstream case outcomes. Staff described several safeguards now in place: disabling immigration and reproductive-health search options in the system's drop-down menus, removing the free-text search box so prohibited terms cannot be typed, auditing access logs, and requiring acknowledgement pages for external agencies requesting Shaker data. The law director also reported that Flock provides insurance (professional liability coverage of $5,000,000 was cited) and that the city is an additional insured under Flock's policy.
