Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Standing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Panel backs bill requiring plaintiffs to show actual harm before suing the state
Summary
House Bill 1971 would require plaintiffs to demonstrate actual injury (standing) before bringing suit against the state; sponsor said the bill mirrors existing standing doctrine and the subcommittee advanced it to full judiciary.
House Bill 1971 would require that individuals suing the state of Tennessee show they have suffered actual harm or injury rather than bringing suits based on hypothetical or potential injuries.
The sponsor described the bill as reflecting standard standing doctrine: plaintiffs must show concrete injury to bring suit rather than mere possibilities. "If someone were to want to sue the state of Tennessee because they think something is wrong and they haven't been damaged or injured and can't show that there's actually been harm, then we can't sue just because something may or is going to happen down the road," the sponsor said. A committee member expressed concern the change could remove causes of action for affected people; the sponsor offered to discuss specifics outside the hearing.
The subcommittee voted to send HB 1971 to full judiciary; the clerk reported 6 ayes and 1 no.
