Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Board Procedure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board amends minutes after debate over secretary election procedure and coin‑toss controversy
Summary
Trustee Carmel Morgan moved to amend the May 18 minutes to record objections to using a coin toss to decide the board secretary election; after debate the board approved the amendment and then elected Trustee Williams as secretary by recorded vote 4–3.
Get email alerts on the Board Procedure topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
At the meeting the board revisited the May 18 minutes and a contested procedure used during the board secretary election. Trustee Carmel Morgan moved to amend the draft minutes to reflect that two nominees had been voted on in a combined vote, the initial vote resulted in a tie, and that the presiding officer had indicated a coin toss would resolve the tie; Morgan asked that the official minutes record objections to using a coin toss to determine an elected official.
Board members debated Robert's Rules and appropriate tie‑breaking methods; one trustee argued the presiding officer does not break ties and that a coin toss "pulls in chance" and should not be used to decide an elected official. The board voted to adopt Morgan's amendment to the minutes (the amendment passed on a voice/hand count). The trustees then conducted a roll/hand vote for secretary: Trustee Williams prevailed by a recorded vote (4 in favor, 3 opposed). The board also approved amended minutes and recorded the no votes and objections for the record.
