Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Library Redevelopment topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission overrides Landmarks Commission, clears way to demolish and rebuild downtown KCK library
Summary
The Unified Government Commission voted unanimously (9'0to'9) to override the Landmarks Commission and the state-review denial and authorized demolition of the library at 625 Minnesota Ave, approving the school board's plan to replace the mid-century building with a new 21st-century library funded from an existing dedicated tax levy.
The Unified Government Commission on July 30 voted 9'to'9 to override a Landmarks Commission denial and to approve both the local certificate of appropriateness and the state-law review that clears the way for demolition and replacement of the downtown library at 625 Minnesota Avenue.
Planning staff and the Landmarks Commission had recommended denial under local historic-preservation standards and state review criteria, saying the building contributes to the downtown historic district. SAP Design Architects partner Brad McKenzie, representing the applicant, told commissioners the existing mid-century structure is operationally inefficient for modern library use: it lacks adequate natural light, has accessibility and fire-suppression constraints, and spatial layouts that hinder safe monitoring. "The most important thing about the downtown library is the place, not the building," McKenzie said, arguing the district's function as a library should be preserved by rebuilding to modern standards.
Kansas City, Kansas Public Schools (KCKPS) and library officials presented options the school board considered and said the board voted to demolish and build a new library after months of study. Officials said funding already exists from a dedicated levy and has been accumulated for this purpose; presenters cited a project cost in the roughly $45'$48 million range (presentation later refined to $46 million; $32 million for the new library plus park improvements and soft costs). The project schedule anticipates design work to begin following approval; construction would begin after administration is relocated and could take roughly 16 months for demolition and rebuilding.
Commissioner Melissa Bynum moved that the commission find—in both the local and state-law reviews—that the school'district'led proposal includes all feasible planning to minimize harm and that no feasible and prudent alternative exists; Commissioner Andrew Davis seconded. Both motions passed unanimously by roll call.
Supporters said a new library would catalyze downtown revitalization and allow the reuse or salvage of historic elements in a redesigned building. Several commissioners asked staff and the applicants to coordinate design work with the Wyandotte Nation and to consider enhanced connections to adjacent Huron Park and Huron Cemetery. Opponents at the Landmarks hearing had urged preservation; the commission's override preserves the library use for the site but allows demolition of the current structure.
Next steps: planning staff and the applicant will coordinate design, consultation with stakeholders (including Wyandotte Nation and parks staff), and timing for relocation of administrative functions before demolition and construction begin.
