Commissioners decline moratorium on CO2 geological storage after mixed testimony

The Jay County Commissioners voted on July 21, 2025 to follow the Jay County Plan Commission's unfavorable recommendation and not impose a moratorium on CO2 geological sequestration storage facilities.

The public hearing drew opposing views. Scott Hopkins, an adjacent landowner to the POET project, said some nearby landowners had not been approached and alleged, "POET drilled their test well without notification to landowners," urging a one‑year moratorium to allow more study. Michael Dunmoyer, a resident, also supported a moratorium, citing concerns about long‑term effects, county liability and potential lowered property values.

POET representatives and contractors urged the commissioners not to impose a moratorium. Adam Homan, POET's general manager, said the project had undergone extensive feasibility studies and processes through the Environmental Protection Agency and the Indiana Department of Natural Resources. Matt Hemenway, a geologist with DTE Vantage hired by POET, described prior carbon‑injection practices and said D2 seismic testing met DNR regulations; he said POET planned outreach to more than 200 landowners in the CO2 footprint.

Jay‑Portland Building & Planning Director John Hemmelgarn reiterated his preference for a moratorium or at least third‑party testing if no moratorium were imposed. After discussion, Commissioner Doug Horn moved to follow the Plan Commission recommendation to not establish a moratorium; Duane Monroe seconded and the motion passed by unanimous vote.

The commissioners indicated they supported third‑party testing and staff outreach, but the formal decision was to decline a moratorium.