Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Climate Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate approves House File 2527, limiting liability in greenhouse-gas claims; critics warn it shields large emitters
Summary
The Senate passed House File 2527 (substituted for Senate File 2427) to limit civil and criminal liability tied to greenhouse-gas emissions, placing the burden of proof on plaintiffs; opponents argued the bill reduces accountability for large industrial emitters. Vote: 33–13.
The Iowa Senate on March 24 approved House File 2527, a bill intended to limit civil and criminal liability for harms alleged to result from greenhouse-gas emissions. Sponsor Senator Shipley said the measure puts the burden of proof on plaintiffs and protects entities operating within permit bounds from broad judicial remedies.
"The bill places the burden of proof on the person bringing the civil action," Senator Shipley said in his opening remarks. He described the legislation as aligning the Senate file with the House version and defended permit-based compliance as a safeguard.
Senator Stade delivered extended floor opposition, arguing the measure would mostly benefit "large scale industrial operations, ethanol producers, and factory farms" and make it "extraordinarily difficult for individual communities or even the state to hold polluters accountable." Stade warned that limiting liability removes incentives to reduce emissions and highlighted public-health concerns linked to air pollution.
After floor debate, the Senate adopted Amendment 5059 (a strike-after amendment expanding the definition of agricultural source and adding petroleum-source definitions), substituted the house file for the senate file by unanimous consent, and voted on final passage. The secretary announced the roll-call as I 33, Nay 13, and declared the bill passed with the title agreed to.
