Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Nightlife Permitting topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Solvang commission denies nightclub CUP for 448 Alisal Road, cites public-safety and noise concerns
Summary
The Solvang Planning Commission voted 4-0 (with one recusal) to deny a conditional use permit for a proposed nightclub at 448 Alisal Road after extensive public comment raised concerns about late-night hours, noise, parking and public safety; denial was without prejudice to allow revisions and reapplication.
The Solvang Planning Commission on Aug. 3 denied a conditional use permit (CUP) for live entertainment at 448 Alisal Road, concluding that the proposed late-night operation posed risks to public health, safety and the village character. The motion to deny without prejudice passed 4-0, with one commissioner recusing because of proximity to the project.
City staff described the proposal as a conversion of an existing 4,500-square-foot basement space to a nightclub/live-entertainment venue, with proposed occupancy increases discussed with the Santa Barbara County Fire Department and an applicant request to operate as late as 2:00 a.m. Rafael, the community development director, said staff recommended a more-limited schedule and conditions including a sheriff-approved security plan and a 65 dB noise limit. "A security plan shall be reviewed and approved by the Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office," Rafael told the commission during the presentation.
The applicant, Ollie Alvarez, told commissioners the venue would host live music, DJs and beverage service and that events would mainly be on weekends. "We will have a beverage, live music, some DJs, and we think it's a plus for the Solvang city," Alvarez said in response to questions about hours and operations.
More than a dozen members of the public urged the commission to deny or narrow the permit. Ingeborg's Danish Chocolate co-owner Kim Jensen warned of potential changes to Solvang's family-oriented character if a 2 a.m. nightclub were approved: "Allowing a business to operate with alcohol service and live entertainment until 2AM in the center of our village would establish a precedence that could fundamentally change the character of our downtown," Jensen said. Other nearby business owners and residents described past late-night incidents tied to similar uses, concerns about trash and sanitation, and limited private parking behind downtown buildings.
Commissioners repeatedly flagged hours, lack of food service, noise mitigation and ADA/egress concerns. One commissioner recused from the decision, reducing the voting body to four; after discussion, Commissioner Taylor (mover) made the denial motion "due to the proposed use constituting a hazard to public health, safety, and welfare, without prejudice," which Commissioner 10 seconded. The motion passed 4-0. Rafael noted denial without prejudice would allow the applicant to revise the proposal and reapply or appeal to city council.
What happens next: The denial was recorded as without prejudice to allow the applicant to work with staff on revisions. The applicant may refile a modified CUP or appeal to the City Council in accordance with the Solvang Municipal Code.
