Commission rejects insurer-driven vinyl-siding fix, approves LP SmartSide replacement on 59 North Trine with conditions

The commission considered two linked applications for 59 North Trine Street. The first application, an insurance-company–recommended vinyl like-for-like replacement, was presented and then rejected by the commission; commissioners said vinyl is inappropriate for the Old Town historic area and would “cheapen” the street when used as a long-term solution (Staff member, speaker 3). A subsequent application proposed LP SmartSide as an alternative that better matches preservation goals.

For the LP SmartSide application commissioners discussed texture (smooth versus wood-grain), corner trim width and whether all four elevations should be finished to match. The commission approved LP SmartSide with conditions: brushed-smooth finish, 6-inch corner trim that protrudes past the lap siding, and matching siding on all four elevations. The approval included a directive that the corner trim be detailed to protrude adequately and that soffits in good condition may remain. The vote was recorded in favor and the amendment requiring all four elevations to be updated carried.

The commission's pattern in this case — rejecting an insurer-led vinyl replacement and approving an alternative material that meets landmarks guidance — highlights the commission's emphasis on material appropriateness in the Old Town area.