Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Telecommunications topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission reviews T‑Mobile antenna upgrade at Mariners Retreat tower; department seeks further study of visual impact
Summary
T‑Mobile proposes to replace existing antennas on the Crown Castle tower at Mariners Retreat Center with arrays extending roughly 84 inches from the tower; planning staff supported the upgrade in principle but asked for additional study to minimize visual and landscape impacts and to preserve the retreat center’s scenic character.
The department presented PZ25‑97: a conditional‑use follow‑up for a telecommunications facility on the Mariners Retreat Center property. The co‑locator, T‑Mobile, proposed replacing smaller exterior elements with a new array that would extend about 84 inches from the tower—substantially more than the 12–36 inches commonly allowed for disguised support structures. Staff said the FAA, federal and state rules limit certain local controls but recommended additional study to minimize visual impacts given the retreat center’s valley setting.
Commissioners expressed concern about the loss of camouflage if the tower is converted from a disguised support structure to a traditional monopole with visible arrays; one commissioner asked, "I don't understand how they're going from 18 inches to 7 feet," reflecting concerns about scale and visibility. Staff noted the city has previously accommodated technology advances while trying to preserve aesthetics and recommended study and wording flexibility in conditions to allow better visual outcomes. The commission voted to accept the department’s information approach and asked staff to return with refined language and study work in the September packet.
