BZA allows Paradise ADU split, permitting two separate parcels where homes already function independently

The Brown County Board of Zoning Appeals approved a variance permitting William and Taryn Paradise to subdivide their parcel so that the accessory dwelling unit (ADU) can be split from the primary residence. Staff told the board the two dwellings have separate driveways, utilities and septic systems; the ADU is roughly 365 feet from the primary residence by straight-line GIS measurement.

Kayla read ordinance language prohibiting use of accessory buildings for human occupancy unless permitted, and explained that section 3.2(c) requires an ADU remain accessory to the primary use and not be sold separately. The petitioners argued the dwellings already function as two residences in practice; Sterling Minor, the listing broker, said the back parcel is nature conservancy and that sale of the primary residence is the motivation for the split. After confirming there are two separate septic systems (one installed in 2014, the other in 2023) the board concluded the split is consistent with how the properties are already used and approved the variance. Danielle advised the petitioners they would need a new address if they proceed.