Senate Judiciary Committee advances William E. Phillips II to appellate confirmation

The Senate Judiciary Committee on a unanimous roll‑call advanced the nomination of William E. Phillips II to the Tennessee Court of Appeals (Eastern section). Senator Stevens introduced Phillips, highlighting his Rogersville roots, a bachelor’s degree from Sewanee and a law degree from the University of Memphis Cecil C. Humphreys School of Law, his work in a family law practice, service as city attorney, and his appointment and election as a circuit judge for the 3rd Judicial District.

Erin Marek, chief counsel to Governor Lee, told the panel the governor had selected Phillips to fill the appellate vacancy and reminded members that judicial candidates must avoid statements that could create future recusal issues. Phillips thanked the committee and his wife before answering questions about judicial decision‑making. When asked how he would handle binding precedent he believed was wrong, Phillips said the court is constrained by existing precedent but added that "if that precedent plainly conflicts with the original language, their public understanding of the original language of a statute, then I think that it is certainly subject to review," and that he would consider concurring or dissenting opinions where appropriate.

After the question period the committee moved and then voted by roll call to accept the nomination for advancement; the secretary recorded nine ayes. The nomination will be considered on the committee’s calendar and advance through the confirmation process.