Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Assessments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Parents question use of 4th-grade IAR/STAR scores for junior-high placement; staff says teacher recommendation and grades weigh most
Summary
Parents said students were placed into accelerated or intervention tracks based on older standardized scores; staff responded that placement uses multiple sources (IAR, end-of-year tests, teacher recommendations, grades) and emphasized teacher recommendation and grades carry the most weight.
Several parents and committee members raised concerns that fourth-grade IAR and STAR scores were being used to place students into junior-high groups and remove them from electives. One parent said their child had strong current class performance but a lower standardized score, which led to intervention placement and lost electives.
Staff responded that placement decisions use a spreadsheet combining IAR scores, end-of-year assessments and teacher recommendations, and said teacher recommendation and current grades are the primary factors. "I would say the biggest stock that we put into those scores are teacher recommendation and their grades," a staff speaker explained, saying standardized tests are "one piece of the puzzle" and that only accelerated classes are leveled while most classes remain heterogeneous.
The committee agreed to revisit the placement process and to ensure clearer communication with families about how assessments and teacher recommendations are combined when assigning students to groups.
