Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Legal Challenge topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Lawmakers cite past court rulings and a lawsuit in criticizing Illinois redistricting
Summary
Republican speakers cited a lawsuit and Illinois Supreme Court precedent on compactness to argue the current legislative maps violate the state constitution; they did not provide case names or court filings on-camera.
Ryan Spain said Republicans had filed a lawsuit alleging Illinois Democrats violated the state constitution's free-and-equal-elections clause and the compactness standard, and referenced earlier Illinois Supreme Court decisions that overturned districts for failing compactness tests. "We were arguing and filed a lawsuit against Illinois Democrats for violating our state constitution...and violating the compactness standard," Spain said.
Spain tied those legal references to a claim that current maps contain numerous districts in violation of compactness standards, saying "we have 52 districts that are in further deeper violation of the compactness standard already established by the Illinois Supreme Court." The video did not present court documents, case names, or legal analysis; presenters offered no on-camera response from the courts or opposing counsel. Verification of the lawsuit and the count of districts the speakers cited is necessary to confirm the claims made in the recording.
