Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planner urges conditional-use approach to curb second-story overhangs; cites state limits on design regulation
Summary
Consulting planner Dave Dixon told the Lighthouse Point commission that new construction techniques are creating second-floor "false balconies" and cantilevers that encroach on setback lines, and recommended a conditional-use process with criteria so the city can protect neighbors' light, air and privacy without running afoul of state design limits.
Consulting city planner Dave Dixon presented a detailed review of how modern construction techniques have pushed ordinary projections and decorative facades into what were historically setback areas, sometimes creating what he called "false balconies" that can affect neighbors' light and privacy. He said the planning and zoning board recommended allowing encroachments only through a conditional-use process with defined criteria and design limits.
"The issue that's been identified is the code does allow certain parts of a building to approach into the setback," Dixon said, explaining that many of the current designs are not traditional eaves or cornices but full facades or cantilevered elements. He noted state law constraints on design regulation and emphasized that the city can still regulate height, bulk, orientation and mitigations "to minimize potential adverse physical or visual impacts to protect the privacy of neighbors." Dixon walked commissioners through examples from Boca Raton, Fort Lauderdale, Surfside and Deerfield and recommended definitions and criteria be developed so the Planning & Zoning Board could evaluate requests.
Commissioners debated whether the city should allow limited encroachments as a conditional use or revise the code to set firm limits. Some said making garage or minor encroachments conditional would preserve discretion, while others worried the approach might invite requests to expand habitable space over time. The commission voted to send the matter back to the Planning & Zoning Board to refine options and consider broadening the conditional-use criteria beyond garages.
The item will return to the commission after Planning & Zoning refines definitions and criteria, likely following the March P&Z meeting.
