Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Rezoning topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning board deadlocks on Vorandesoto/Xcel rezoning; approves conditional permit with conditions
Summary
On Aug. 5, 2025 the Silver Creek Township Board of Planning and Zoning recorded a 4-4 tie on a rezoning motion for a Vorandesoto/Xcel Energy site and separately approved an interim use permit (IUP) with several conditions; the minutes note debate over industrial vs. commercial use.
On Aug. 5, 2025 the Silver Creek Township Board of Planning and Zoning failed to pass a rezoning motion for a property associated with Vorandesoto and Xcel Energy after a 4-4 tie. The board then approved an interim use permit (IUP) with stated conditions; the minutes record the IUP motion carried 8-0.
The rezoning motion was made by board member Brandon Geyen and seconded by Ryan Nelson and "does not pass at 4-4," according to the meeting minutes. Chairman Chris Klein subsequently made a motion to approve an IUP "with stated conditions, should the rezoning pass," and the minutes record that motion "carried 8-0." The minutes list conditions including no access to 148th, no overnight lighting unless motion controlled except at entrances, a stormwater plan approved by WCSW, a dust control plan, compliance with county traffic signage and requirements, and further discussion about mitigating backup noise.
Minutes summarize contrasting viewpoints: some attendees or board members described the proposed industrial use as a "good use with minimal disturbance" that had been vacant too long, while others argued the parcel might be better utilized as commercial land because of its location. The minutes do not attribute those comments to specific board members.
The meeting record is ambiguous about the effect of the tie vote on the IUP: the IUP motion is recorded as carried 8-0 "should the rezoning pass," but the minutes do not specify whether the IUP was intended to take effect despite the rezoning vote failing on a 4-4 tie. The board did not record individual roll-call votes by name in the minutes provided.
The board adjourned after the other business was completed. Minutes do not show further procedural steps, appeals, or timelines for implementation of the IUP or any next hearings on rezoning.
