Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Views And Neighborhood Character topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents ask Monterey Park to study municipal-code changes after six‑foot fence blocks long‑standing hillside views
Summary
Neighbors urged the City Council to consider new municipal-code protections after a recently installed six‑foot vinyl fence on a hillside parcel obstructed decades‑old views for longstanding residents; staff agreed to investigate possible code amendments and return options to council.
Carla Smith Holtmeier told the council she was speaking for her mother, Betty Denny Smith, whose home at 1766 Bluff Hill Drive lost a view she and her family have enjoyed for decades after a neighbor built a white vinyl fence.
"The view was spectacular," Holtmeier said, describing photos she provided that show the view from the early 1960s compared with 2026. She said the family consulted real-estate professionals who estimated a loss in property value in the range of $150,000 to $200,000 tied to the view’s obstruction.
Linda Wu, a 58‑year resident, said she and several neighbors tried to negotiate with the property owner—offering to pay to lower the wall—but the neighbor declined and completed the fence on Jan. 14. Wu said the neighbors have submitted a draft municipal-code provision in the meeting packet that would require homeowners to obtain prior consent from those whose original views would be obstructed by fences, plantings or structures.
"The fence not only impacts my feelings of personal space and tranquility, but it also devalues my property," Wu said, urging council action to prevent similar losses for other long‑term residents.
Council members asked staff whether the municipal code currently regulates fence heights on hillsides. Staff said the municipal code contains maximum fence-height standards but does not require neighbor consent before a fence or planting that would obstruct a long‑standing view. Several council members said they were sympathetic to the speakers and asked staff to research options the city could lawfully pursue going forward.
Assistant staff offered to investigate potential municipal-code amendments and to report back to council. The mayor noted the topic was not on the night's agenda and framed staff investigation as the next step; no formal code change was adopted at the meeting.
