Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the 20 Pray topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
HDC denies proposed house at 20 Pray Street amid rooftop‑deck and massing concerns
Summary
The Portsmouth Historic District Commission denied Blue Sky Development's application for a new single‑family house and detached garage/ADU at 20 Pray Street by a 4–3 vote after commissioners and neighbors raised concerns about rooftop decks, garage massing and incompatible styling with Pray Street.
The Portsmouth Historic District Commission voted 4–3 to deny Blue Sky Development’s application for a new house and detached garage at 20 Pray Street after an extended public hearing and robust commissioner questioning.
Tracy Kozak, Arcove Architects, presented the plan as a cape‑style house with a recessed roof deck and an attached single‑car garage with bonus space. Kozak explained the rooftop deck was recessed three feet below the roof line and would not show railings from the public way. "It's recessed below the roof line, and there's no elements that would suggest a deck that you can see," Kozak said, describing the feature.
Neighbors and several commissioners disagreed that the deck was unobtrusive. Commissioner Kate Cook told the panel she was "struggling" with the styling and called rooftop decks inappropriate in the tight South End: "I don't think that rooftop decks should exist in this neighborhood." Other commissioners questioned whether the garage massing and front boxes made the design feel too modern and out of step with Pray Street’s simpler houses.
After deliberation commissioners took a roll‑call style vote; the application failed 4–3. The commission’s denial was grounded in concerns about style, roof massing and neighborhood compatibility. The applicant may revise and return to a future meeting.
