Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Nonconforming Use topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board tables request to allow outdoor ice sales at 328 Bassett after neighborhood concerns
Summary
An application to permit an ice machine and outside sales at Village Rose (agenda listed as Christy Malloy of Village Rose) was tabled after the applicant (who identified in the record as Christine Loy) and neighbors debated whether outside sales enlarge a long‑standing nonconforming retail use. Neighbors warned of precedent and incremental commercial expansion.
The Bay Village Zoning Appeals Board on June 18 deferred a decision on a request to allow outdoor sales at 328 Bassett, including an ice machine and potentially a firewood box. The agenda listed the applicant as Christy Malloy of Village Rose; the person speaking for the application identified herself in the record as Christine Loy. After extended discussion of zoning precedent and public comment, the applicant chose to table the matter to a future meeting.
Board members and staff reviewed past case law and the municipal code, including a 1979 BZA finding and code sections the board said apply to nonconforming retail uses (discussion referenced 11/25 and 11/73). Staff and a board member explained the longstanding interpretation that sales outside the four walls can be treated as an enlargement of the use and therefore require a permit; one member summarized that an ice machine “would be an expansion of the use.” Neighbors and residents said incremental changes could erode the residential character: Roger Herman told the board he feared a “stepping stone” to other outdoor commercial activity, and resident Richard Reguski warned that allowing outside sales could diminish the value of zoning protections.
The applicant described interior space constraints and power access as reasons the ice machine was sited outside and said smaller (5‑pound) bags are offered; she said the outdoor unit “doesn’t make any noise at all.” Board members suggested the permit could be narrowly tailored — limiting the machine size, attaching the permit to the business rather than the property, or requiring annual renewal — but the applicant asked to table the request while clarifying the application. A motion to table the application for 328 Bassett carried on roll call.
