Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Materials And Compatibility topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
HDC conditions approval at 599 Ocean Ave; PVC trim rejected in favor of painted wood
Summary
After extended discussion about durability and precedent, the commission required painted wood trim for 599 Ocean Ave and approved the application with that condition, citing district compatibility standards.
At its Sept. 15 meeting the Newport Historic District Commission approved the application for 599 Ocean Ave on the condition that exterior trim be replaced with painted wood rather than PVC. The preservation planner had flagged PVC as incompatible with the district’s standards; commissioners debated durability in a harsh marine environment versus the risk of creating a material precedent.
Applicant representatives argued PVC would last longer in that exposed location, but commissioners repeatedly emphasized the commission’s materials standards. One commissioner stated plainly, “I would not be in favor of, using PVC.” The applicant agreed to convert proposed trim to painted wood (the applicant mentioned using mahogany) and the commission approved the application with that explicit condition. Provenance: topicintro SEG 408, topfinish SEG 636.
