Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Instructional Materials Voucher topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Board ratifies voucher for children’s book after heated debate over message
Summary
The board ratified expense voucher 1005, despite objections from a board member who said the chosen book (Elmer) was inappropriate for elementary students because of publisher ties; other board members defended the book as age-appropriate and centered on self-acceptance. The ratification passed by voice vote (2–1).
Board member Van Hook requested that voucher 1005 be pulled, expressing concern about a book purchased for elementary students (Elmer), saying she believed the publisher’s association and promotion made the book inappropriate for the district. She argued the book’s publisher has promoted Pride campaigns and said parents did not have an opt-out for the purchase.
President Wade and other board members described Elmer as a children’s tale about a patchwork elephant and self-acceptance and pushed back on the claim that the book was unsuitable. President Wade summarized the story and said the book teaches acceptance: “It’s called Elmer. It’s about an elephant. It’s a patchwork elephant... he learns how to find it within himself.” After discussion the board ratified the voucher (motion carried, recorded voice vote indicated two in favor and one opposed).
The debate highlighted differing views among board members about instructional materials and how publishers’ broader activities (outside the book text) should influence selection for classroom use. Administration said the purchase was meant to support literacy and social‑emotional learning in an age‑appropriate way.
