Neighbors object as Zoning Board splits decisions on contested Second Street rebuild

A proposed demolition and rebuild at 7588 Second Street drew sustained neighborhood opposition at the June 9 Zoning Board meeting over size, height and parking, and the board split its rulings on separate variances.

Representatives for the applicants (Daniel Pope speaking for the homeowners) presented plans that advertised a three‑story/34‑foot structure with a 14.7‑foot front setback and up to roughly 40% lot coverage. Neighbors questioned the scale, possible conversion to rentals, and the impact on parking and adjacent cottages; several asked the board to require reductions. One emailed public comment from Jean Hallagan urged the homeowner to keep additions toward the backyard and noted local parking pressures.

The board voted separately on three variance components. It approved a motion to allow the garage/setback as proposed (5' from rear property line) on a 4–0 vote. A motion to accept the listed 34‑foot height failed 0–4; members referenced Planning Board recommendations for 30 feet and CEO remarks about elevation and measurement. A motion to permit 40% lot coverage also failed 0–4. Tom Johns noted the advertised figures and the complexity of measuring height when grades vary; CEO Kevin Druschel confirmed advertised materials could not be changed mid‑hearing. The board left unresolved whether a revised application with reduced height or coverage would be resubmitted.

Why it matters: the split decision allows one aspect (garage setback) while denying the higher‑density and height requests, reflecting board caution about neighborhood character and Planning Board guidance.