Council pushes for more data before extending five engineering contracts
Sep 15, 2026
City engineering staff asked the Livonia City Council to extend five qualification-based selection contracts for five years to keep consultant capacity for time-sensitive grant-funded projects; council members pressed for market comparisons and a memo showing cost savings before final approval at the Sept. 28 meeting.
The full story
Engineering staff asked the council to approve five-year extensions of qualification-based selection (QBS) contracts with OHM Advisors, Hubbell, Roth & Clark, Spalding & Decker, and Anderson, Eckstein & Westrick, arguing that consultant continuity lets the city pursue time-sensitive federal and state grants and complete complex designs.
"We are requesting that these... 5 year extension be awarded to these firms," Engineer Todd said, citing recent projects where consultants helped secure federal aid and coordinate multiple signal and road upgrades. Staff pointed to the Newberg Road reconstruction as an example of coordinated funding, saying the project totaled about $3,700,000 and that leveraging consultants helped obtain grant portions and complete work more quickly.
Council members welcomed the firms' past performance but repeatedly asked why staff would not re-open the market. "I just wanna see a little bit more documentation," Councilmember McCullough said, asking for a comparison memo showing market alternatives and the percentage savings staff attributed to retaining incumbent firms. Several council members noted the fee schedule dates to 2010 and asked for current comparative figures and an explanation of why the city should waive a fresh RFQ now.
Staff replied the QBS fee schedule was established in 2010 and has been updated for inflation and that retaining experienced consultants can reduce the city's costs and timeline on federally funded projects. Staff said there is a 0.7% design discount for continuing contractors to save funds for road work. Councilmembers directed staff to return the item to the Sept. 28 regular meeting with the requested documentation before voting.
The council did not take a final vote at the study session; engineering staff will prepare the requested memo and comparative materials for the regular meeting packet.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
