Appellate panel weighs whether Rule 41 technical errors still require suppression in State v. Morton

Sep 16, 2026

At oral argument in State of Tennessee v. William Morton, defense counsel argued that a trial court did not find "good faith" as to a failure to serve a warrant and asked the panel to apply precedent from Lowe and Daniel; the state urged dismissal or remand, saying the certified question is not dispositive.

The full story

An appellate panel heard oral argument in State of Tennessee v. William Morton over whether the trial court properly ruled on a Rule 41 technical violation and whether the Tennessee Supreme Court's rulings in Lowe and Daniel remain controlling. Defense counsel Drew Justice told the panel, "This appeal is about whether the Tennessee Supreme Court meant for us actually to follow its rulings in State versus Lowe and State versus Daniel, or whether, as the state thinks, it only meant to apply, those rulings in those particular cases, leaving trial judges in all future cases just to do pretty much whatever they want." Justice asked the court to decide whether a Rule 41 error committed without good faith requires suppression under existing precedent.

Free newsletter

Sign up to keep reading.

Your free newsletter brings you what your city council, county, and school board discussed and decided.

or
Already have an account? Sign in