State board adopts San Diego basin‑plan amendment to add biological objective using CSCI
Aug 19, 2026
The State Water Resources Control Board unanimously approved a San Diego basin‑plan amendment that incorporates a biological condition objective based on the California Stream Condition Index (CSCI) and includes findings clarifying how the objective will be implemented in stormwater permits and for flood‑control maintenance.
The full story
The State Water Resources Control Board on Aug. 18 unanimously adopted a Region 9 basin‑plan amendment to incorporate a biological condition objective using the California Stream Condition Index, a peer‑reviewed bioassessment tool. Chad Laughlin, senior environmental scientist for the San Diego Regional Water Board, told the board the measure rests on more than a decade of regional monitoring, four independent peer reviewers and multi‑year outreach.
"Biological integrity is really a core component of the Clean Water Act," Laughlin said, summarizing the regional process and noting that findings before the board clarify implementation for municipal stormwater permits and for temporary flood‑control maintenance activities. The resolution includes a set of findings (finding 15) that, among other things, says a low CSCI score in a stream does not automatically put MS4 permittees into noncompliance and that permits will specify the process for assessing whether MS4 discharges are causing or contributing to a low score.
Stakeholders from environmental groups and permittees largely supported the amendment. Marty Pfau of California Coastkeeper Alliance told the board that the CSCI "is a scientifically robust tool" and that biological measures better capture habitat and cumulative stressors that chemical testing can miss. Several municipal and flood‑control representatives, including Amanda Carr of Orange County stormwater programs, praised added implementation clarity ahead of an expected wet winter.
Board members said the amendment represents a collaborative solution but urged caution on broader statewide application where data coverage is thinner. Board member Jared Blumenfeld asked how up‑to‑date the CSCI data are in public web apps; Laughlin and staff pointed to the State Water Board's data exchange (CDN) and recent SEDEN updates as the authoritative sources. Vice Chair Doreen D'Adamo moved adoption of the resolution with two change sheets and the board approved the measure by unanimous roll call.
The resolution will be added to the Region 9 basin plan during an upcoming triennial review and staff said the findings are intended to guide permit writers and regional staff as the objective is implemented. The board recorded no dissent and said the item establishes a template other regions may adapt with appropriate local data.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
