State board adopts Region 9 amendment to use CSCI as a biological objective

Aug 21, 2026

The State Water Resources Control Board unanimously adopted a Region 9 basin plan amendment adding a biological water‑quality objective based on the California Stream Condition Index (CSCI), with findings clarifying implementation for municipal stormwater and flood‑control maintenance permits.

The full story

The State Water Resources Control Board voted unanimously on Aug. 18 to adopt a Region 9 basin plan amendment that incorporates a biological water‑quality objective based on the California Stream Condition Index (CSCI).

Chad Laughlin, a senior environmental scientist with the San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board, told the board the CSCI was peer reviewed, field‑tested in the San Diego region over multiple years, and supported by independent scientific reviewers. "We used the best available science that's vetted in the San Diego region," Laughlin said during his presentation, noting the project also underwent extensive public outreach from 2016 through 2020.

The adopted findings (finding 15) clarify that municipal stormwater permittees are not immediately noncompliant if a low CSCI score appears in a stream channel, that permits will specify how to evaluate whether MS4 discharges are causing or contributing to low CSCI scores, and that permittees will not be required to alter stream‑channel engineering solely because of a low CSCI score. The findings also provide that routine flood‑control maintenance activities may temporarily lower CSCI scores and will not be barred or require pre/post monitoring in all cases.

Environmental groups and permittees who participated in the multi‑year stakeholder process supported the resolution. "The science is sound. The process has been more than thorough," said Marty Farrell, a staff attorney with the California Coastkeeper Alliance, urging adoption. Regional board chair Gary Straughan and several board members commended the Region 9 staff and stakeholders for a consensus‑building process that addressed implementation concerns.

Vice Chair Doreen D'Adamo moved adoption of the resolution, which included two chain‑sheet clarifications; Chair Joaquin Esquivel seconded the motion. Clerk Courtney Tyler called a roll‑call vote and the board recorded unanimous approval. The resolution will be incorporated into the Region 9 basin plan during an upcoming triennial review and staff said the implementation language is intended to provide clarity for municipal stormwater permits and flood‑control activities going forward.

Board members flagged broader state‑level issues: while expressing support, some asked for guidance on how the tool might or might not apply beyond the San Diego region and urged state staff to consider data availability and reference‑site distribution when advising other regions. Staff pointed board members to the California Environmental Data Exchange Network (CDEN) and statewide SWAMP monitoring as sources for CSCI and supporting data.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓