Baker Tilly recommends annual time-and-position pay adjustments in Johnson County study
Jun 17, 2026
Consultants told the Johnson County Board of Supervisors that the county's pay structure is broadly competitive with peers, and offered three implementation options — the board signaled support for an annual time-and-position adjustment (option 3) pending a formal vote next week.
The full story
Sarah Towne, senior manager for Baker Tilly's classification and compensation team, presented a five-phase study to the Johnson County Board of Supervisors on June 17 that evaluated 146 county positions and benchmarked roughly 102 roles against 10 peer organizations.
Towne said the county's overall pay structure is competitive in the market, citing the county's cost-of-labor index at 92.6 on a U.S.-100 scale and reporting in the presentation that the county is "18.3% ahead of market at the minimum, 17% ahead of market at the midpoint, and 14.3% ahead of market at the maximum." She told supervisors the study used SAFE job-evaluation scores and external market matches to produce grade assignments across the county's 21 pay grades.
The consultants laid out three implementation scenarios. Option 1 would bring four outlier employees up to the proposed structure (Towne's presentation listed an estimated cost of $1,813.60). Option 2 would move broadly to minimums or provide a flat increase affecting roughly 265 employees and, according to the presentation, would add about $606,564.18 on top of a planned 2.6% cost-of-living adjustment. Option 3 — the time-and-position approach the consultants described as an annual 3% step per year in role to ease compression — was presented with a smaller headline cost in the slide materials and described as the board's most targeted way to address tenure and internal equity.
Several supervisors said they preferred Option 3 because it better accounts for time in a position; others favored the lower-cost Option 1. Board members asked about implementation timing, the study budget (staff said the county had budgeted $63,000 for the survey and billing to date was about $40,900) and whether the county could implement changes in the new fiscal year. County staff and consultants said detailed placement spreadsheets would be shared with the full board and the item would be returned for a formal vote at the next formal meeting.
Towne recommended continuing SAFE-based maintenance and annual reviews to keep the pay plan aligned with market conditions. "We would stick with them. Continue doing COLAs, continue doing merit, and evaluating both on an annual basis," she said in the presentation.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
