Homeowner setback variance denied after neighbors and board question practical difficulty

Sep 29, 2026

The Board of Zoning Appeals denied a request for a setback variance for a backyard pool deck, after neighbors and the HOA raised covenant and setback concerns and the board found insufficient practical difficulty to justify relief.

The full story

The Carmel Board of Zoning Appeals voted to deny Cole Breininger’s request for a side‑yard setback variance for a pool deck at the meeting on Sept. 28.

Breininger told the board the deck was built to improve safety for his family ahead of the birth of his first child and sits behind a six‑foot privacy fence, out of public view. He said his contractor had advised a permit was unnecessary and that, once the issue was raised, he applied for an after‑the‑fact permit and pursued the variance. "This deck improves the safety and usability around the pool for our family," Breininger said during his presentation.

Neighbors and the Cool Creek Estates HOA opposed the variance. John Fitzgerald described the structure as a post‑completion violation and told the board, "In violation of the 5 foot accessory setback rule specified in city building code, an elevated structure of approximately 650 square feet was built this past spring at 1507 Cool Creek Drive." HOA president Susan McClain asked that the HOA’s letter and covenant provisions be included in the record and reiterated that HOA approval is a private matter separate from the BZA’s zoning review.

Planning staff noted the property is enclosed by a privacy fence and recommended positive consideration, but board members split on whether a legal "practical difficulty" existed. After discussion, a motion to approve the variance was made and seconded but failed in the vote, and the board declined to grant the setback relief.

The denial leaves the property unchanged under current zoning; neighbors discussed HOA remedies and private enforcement options during the hearing. The petitioner and remonstrators were given the record for any follow‑up; no further action on the item was announced at adjournment.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓