Power Advisory frames RECA study as a decision framework, not a procurement directive
Sep 29, 2026
Power Advisory told the Maryland Public Service Commission its RECA study is a toolkit to match procurement models to identified policy goals — not an instruction to procure particular projects. The firm ranked index REC, competitive dialogue and PPAs highly under a multi‑criteria analysis and recommended additional sensitivity analysis and stakeholder input before a final report.
The full story
The Maryland Public Service Commission heard Friday that the consultant retained to study procurement methods under the Renewable Energy Certainty Act intends its work to inform policy choices rather than direct them.
"Our study is meant to be a decision framework and not a procurement decision," Power Advisory analyst Nanako Yano told commissioners as she summarized the firm’s August 17 preliminary report. Yano said the firm compared nine procurement models using three analyses — a multi‑criteria decision analysis (MCDA), technology mapping and a "least‑regrets" test — and assessed models against three policy objectives: resource adequacy, affordability and speed to market.
Why it matters: the study is intended to give policymakers a structured way to pick and design a procurement model once they define the problem they want solved — the quantity, timing and attributes of the resources sought. Yano said the report does not recommend a specific technology or project and does not constitute a procurement plan.
Power Advisory presented ranked results tied to each objective. Under resource adequacy the top models were index REC, competitive dialogue and PPAs; affordability favored index REC and PPAs; speed to market ranked PPAs and index REC highest. The firm also offered a technology mapping showing, for example, PPAs and index REC typically suit mature, competitive resources like solar while competitive dialogue better fits complex, long‑lead projects such as offshore wind; partial tolling may suit dispatchable resources like batteries and gas.
Stakeholder concerns: John Dalton of Power Advisory summarized seven sets of comments the firm received and flagged disputes over how the report scored utility‑owned generation. "We will reassess these benefits" in the final report, Dalton said, and the firm plans to add sensitivity analysis and consider whether legal‑feasibility thresholds are appropriate before models are formally scored.
Next steps: Power Advisory said the comments heard at the technical conference and commissioner feedback will shape a final report the firm expects to deliver in time for the commission to file a report to the legislature by the December 1 statutory deadline.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
