Defense calls alleged pretrial "stipulation" a "phantom stipulation," flags missing transcript

Jul 15, 2026

Pat McNally told the panel he could not find a May 20 pretrial transcript that had been relied on at trial and filed a supplemental record; he said reliance on an alleged stipulation muddled the record and undercuts the trial court's later findings.

The full story

During rebuttal, Pat McNally told the court he had located and filed a missing May 20 transcript that he said the trial judge had apparently relied upon when describing a pretrial agreement. "It's a phantom stipulation," McNally said, arguing the record did not contain the stipulation the trial judge referenced and that reliance on notes or an absent transcript created confusion.

Free newsletter

Sign up to keep reading.

Your free newsletter brings you what your city council, county, and school board discussed and decided.

or
Already have an account? Sign in