Commissioners press engineers on culvert sizing, fish passage rules and mitigation costs

Oct 6, 2026

Commissioners challenged staff on large culvert replacements and mitigation costs; staff said Fish and Wildlife standards and habitat priorities are driving upsizing and that counties have pushed back on rule timelines.

The full story

During the Six'Year Plan presentation, committee members pressed Susan on whether the county is oversizing culverts for seasonal streams and what authority determines design standards. A commissioner asked, "Fish are in water. They're in water," to underline skepticism about large structures being needed for occasional flows.

Susan replied that culverts are sized with continuous storm models and that the county aims to size for a 50'year storm at minimum and, where practical, the 100'year event. She also said there is "a standard for fish culverts that was developed by Fish and Wildlife, and it's based on the ordinary high water mark," and that the state'level rulemaking effort has been controversial because proposed timelines could force replacement of older culverts that are still structurally sound.

Commissioners also pressed the county's capacity to challenge or seek exceptions during design or installation and raised mitigation costs and the use of mitigation banks. Susan described mitigation banks near Kelso where the county can purchase credits but noted watershed restrictions can limit availability. One commissioner called some mitigation approaches a "sham," arguing that off'site mitigation can fail to match local effects; the meeting recorded no binding answer but flagged mitigation availability and cost as an important constraint on project timing and budgeting.

Why it matters: culvert and fish passage design drives large parts of the county's capital need and can substantially increase local matches on grant'funded projects. Commissioners requested clearer cost estimates and more local options to challenge design decisions.

Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓