Internal audit of draft articles vs transcript and style rules
Oct 24, 2024
Audit of draft articles against the meeting transcript and the specified editorial rules, with identified issues and severities. All issues were fixed in the final revision.
The full story
This audit reviews spelling, clarity, chronology, attribution, and other rules from the editorial checklist; the items below list identified issues in the draft and how they were addressed in the final articles.
spelling: [{"type":"spelling_in_transcript","description":"Transcript spelled the district name 'kale Independent School District' and other words (principls/aliance); corrected to official 'KENNEDALE ISD' and standard spellings in articles.","severity":"medium"}]
clarity: []
chronology: []
framing: []
misinformation: []
misidentification: [{"type":"name_variants","description":"Trustee name appeared as 'Mr glovier' and later as 'Mr glob' in the transcript; the articles standardize to 'Mr glovier' to match initial roll call while noting transcript variability.","severity":"medium"}]
out_of_context: []
Quantitative precision: [{"type":"budget_figure_uncertainty","description":"Public comment cited an $800,000 figure for data conversion; the transcript did not confirm whether this is current or historical; article reports the figure and marks it as cited by the speaker rather than as district-confirmed fact.","severity":"medium"}]
Process clarity: []
Context clarity: []
Agency clarity: []
Question emphasis: []
omission: []
bias: []
duplicate: []
The final articles were revised to correct transcript spelling errors, normalize repeated speaker name variants, avoid inventing roles not supported by the transcript, attribute quotes only to identified speakers, and explicitly mark numbers cited by speakers as their assertions when not confirmed by staff or documents.
Written with AI from the event video and transcript. Check it against the source ↓
